6 Gyms and a Snax Cafe Breakfast :o)

In the light of my recent announcement regarding the sad closure of Factory Gyms and with our livelihoods now under threat Kyle Farningham, currently my fellow personal trainer here at Factory and also the manager of Urban Gym Edinburgh, and I thought it would be prudent to check out some other facilities :)

With this in mind we headed out to see what we could find within walking distance of Factory. We only found seven gyms but we checked out six of them anyway and here’s our verdict for you all :)

I would firstly like to state that every single gym can be a bit crowded at peak times. That’s why I train in an afternoon :) I should also mention firstly that I already train myself at Thompsons in Leith and Pure Gym at both Ocean Terminal and The Meadows. I’ve always used multiple gyms. I’m a bit of a gym slut :)

Thompsons is a bodybuilding gym and an excellent facility if this is what you are looking for. It has lots of excellent equipment – 45% Leg Press, Hack Squat, Smith Machine, a few Hammer Strength (my favourite equipment range) pieces etc, plenty of free weight and exceptionally heavy (160lb plus) dumbbells. It’s friendly, privately owned, reasonably priced (£20 a month off peak) and all it’s really lacking is floor space.

Pure are the latest cheap ‘n’ cheerful style of gym chain. The new ‘The Gym’ opening in Waverley Gate is the same style operation. There are plenty of machines and cardio equipment (Matrix) and it’s good. There are free weights but less than at Thompsons or Factory but no less than at most other gyms in the city though, as we will see. The price is amazingly cheap at only £16 a month with no contract. I’ve trained in both venues in the city, the Meadows and Ocean Terminal and while I prefer the open plan layout at the Meadows I use Ocean Terminal more often as it’s more convenient and the kits the same. Lovely view of the city too, seriously :)

Let’s move on now to today’s adventure report :) I was really tempted to use the good, the bad and the ugly as my sub headings but I’ve somewhat uncharacteristically restrained myself :)

The Hotels

We visited 3 hotel gyms. First up was the Carlton Hotel. This was a bit poor to be honest. Run down and rather shabby they haven’t fixed the floor since Factory owner Tom Robertson worked there over 2 years ago :) The equipment isn’t bad as such but there isn’t a lot of it. It’s nowhere near as good as Thompsons or Pure and as neither of us fancy taking either ourselves or our clients there we move on and don’t even ask what the prices are :)

The Scotsman Gym

Our second stop is at The Scotsman. I like it here, so does Kyle. It is clean and well presented. The gym area is small but has everything you need and a nice atmosphere. I can’t remember what the kit was, Kyle thinks it was Cybex and I think he’s right :) It was good anyway :) Not lots of free weights but enough given the size of the facility. I am shocked when Kyle tells me it is £60 a month to be a member here though. I’ll be looking in to this place further and Kyle is investigating getting a deal here too. I’ll keep you posted :)

The Breakfast :)

The Scotsman Pool looking so cool I had to include this pic :)

We stopped at this point to visit Snax Cafe, a traditional greasy spoon, an Edinburgh institution and one of our favourite places :) Today we go there and eat in, sometimes they deliver to us but we’re always happy. We recommend the Biggest breakfast (2 Link Sausage, Bacon, Fried Egg, Black Pudding, Tattie Scone, Hash Brown, Haggis, Sliced Sausage, Beans, Fried Tomato & Buttered Roll) and a big latte :)

The Scotsman Hotel looking so amazing I inclued this too :)

The Last Hotel

The third hotel we visit is The Roxburghe. Kyle’s comment of ‘It’s like walking into someone’s living room’ about covers it :) It has some nice Techno Gym kit but only 2 flat benches and a few dumbbells :( Cleaner and better presented than the Carlton though. Again we don’t even ask prices :)

The Health Clubs

Our next stop is Bannantynes on Queens Street. Kyle and I are given forms to fill in while we wait for Christina the membership girl .We are amused, very amused :) The gym is disappointing. I forget what the kit was but the gym was small and cramped, especially for £48 and a minimum 6 months contract. There is a pool and studios and classes and sauna things iirc and these are included in the membership but we’re not interested in these or the dual membership we’re offered so we wander off to our next stop :)

Virgin at the Omni Centre is spacious and well equipped and it has a pool and studios and saunas and jacuzzis and towels too :) I like it here but it’s also £57 a month which seems expensive, especially when compared to Pure. It equates to an extra £41 a month for lots of ‘extras’ which I’d most likely never use. The other Virgin in the city is half the size Naomi the membership girl tells us so we decide not to visit there at all :)

The Gym

Yes we also visited a gym :) It was actually the first place we visited but it was the best so I saved it for last :) The Centre For Sporting Excellence (CSE) at the Pleasance is brilliant :) It’s by far the best facility we visited in terms of equipment, size and price. There are literally 100’s of pieces of cardio equipment, loads of machines, plenty of free weights, heavy (70kg or so) dumbbells and everything else you can think of spread over 5 rooms and it’s only £29 a month :) We both like this a lot and it gets our vote for the best gym of the day :)

CSE cardio room

Coming Soon….

Stay tuned for part 2 when David Lloyds (not looking forward to this, I’ll have to fill a form in :( ), One Spa (quite excited about this as I’ve never been) and anywhere else I can think of in the meantime are on the list :) If you can think of anywhere comment below please :)

4 Responses to “6 Gyms and a Snax Cafe Breakfast :o)”

Read below or add a comment...

  1. Allan Christie says:

    Really interesting read this and great for people like me who will (unfortunately) be looking for a new gym to join once Factory’s closes. :(

    Reading through the gym reviews by Matt I personally will probably join the Pure Gym at the Ocean Terminal. The reasons being the price, 10 Min’s from where I stay and it seems to have a good range of Cardio equipment and some wights too!! I will take a look at some of the other gyms Matt and Kyle have reviewed but if I’m being honest for someone like me Pure Gym will probably suit myself best.

    Although it could also depend on what gym has the best looking talent (female of course!!) ;) I can easily burn 500 calories by just watching a lovely bird in tight Lycra!! :) :)

    I usually train around late afternoon just because of my shifts and it tends to be quieter around this time although I don’t mind training in peak times too!! Well after reading this review on the various gyms I suppose it’s time to go out and check some of them out. One thing is for sure, I don’t think any of the gyms will have as friendly staff as the ones at Factory, they really do add to the experience of going to the gym.

    I wish Matt and Kyle and all the rest of the staff at Factory gyms the very best for the future!!

  2. Gordon Rogers says:

    I’m currently a member of Factory Gyms and really disappointed that it’s closing. In the past I’ve been a member of two of the gyms reviewed here – Scotsman and the CSE (before it’s refurb and extension). Both are decent, but neither have the same feel as Factory.

    Scotsman Pro’s
    * small and friendly gym keeps a bit of the atmosphere
    * the pool and spa area is incredible
    * decent enough selection of free weights
    * excellent pilates instructor

    Scotsman Con’s
    * The price
    * No squat rack

    CSE Pro’s
    * The price
    * Variety of equipment
    * Squash courts

    CSE Con’s
    * Always busy
    * A bit of a labryinth
    * Impersonal

  3. Jim Little says:

    Matt / Kyle

    Thanks for this review, it’s really helpful. It would be useful to get an idea of how busy these places are at different times of the day. I went to look at Pure Gym at Ocean Terminal about midday and it was really quiet. At 7.00 pm it was absolutely heaving. Whilst it has loads of cardio kit, the majority was being used and the free weight area was bursting at the seams, with people hanging around waiting to use kit. For me, if I have to wait to use kit I tend to pack up and leave as I like to just get on with my training. I don’t know what that says about my motivation but how busy a gym is at the time I like to use it is very important to me. Conversely, I don’t want it to be completely empty as seeing others working out is also motivational, and I don’t want to be alone when Jack Nicholson walks in with a chopping axe!

  4. Drew says:

    Gutted to hear about Factory. I’d still be there if I hadn’t moved jobs.

    I’m at Pure next to the meadows and my choice was based on 2 things:
    1. It’s right next to my flat
    2. It’s cheap

    You’re right about peak times. It’s almost impossible to get near the free weights on an evening.
    I usually go about 9pm to avoid the long rush hour. :-)

    Pros:
    Cheap
    Decent kit
    24 hour opening
    Hot students by the thousand

    Cons:
    No one puts the ruddy weights back
    The turnstyles to get in are a bit tight (they obviously don’t like fat folk – I may complain)
    Gangsters
    The dumb bells only go up to 30kg
    There are no 20kg bars… (Are you sure? There were at least 2 when I was last there – Matt)
    When I asked if they had a trap bar (and described it) the PT just looked confused.

    If it wasn’t cheap I’d probably just leave.

    I’d love to see Factory move in and replace them.

    Matt, if you’re round there training on an evening let me know!

Leave A Comment...

*